FOOD INTOLERANCE NETWORK FACTSHEET

line1

Failsafe weight loss

Failsafers often tell us the RPAH elimination diet helps them to lose weight. See their stories below. Note, we always recommend a dietitian-supervised elimination diet.

Summary

  • avoidance of UPFs reduces food cravings
  • food intolerance symptoms can be associated with weight gain
  • dropping medications that cause weight gain
  • the most effective long term weight loss diet
  • potato-only diet
  • commercial weight loss programs
  • low fat failsafe
  • successful losers
  • references and further reading

1. Avoidance of UPFs reduces food cravings

In the world's first ever study to compare ultra-processed versus minimally or unprocessed diets, Stanford researchers found when 20 healthy adults who were provided with 2 weeks each of ultra-processed or unprocessed diets, participants on average gained nearly half a kilo a week on the ultra-processed diet and lost nearly half a kilo a week on the unprocessed diet (1, see blog Ultra-processed foods linked to obesity). The RPAH elimination diet avoids ultra-processed foods (UPFs), and failsafers report similar benefits.

“We are doing the elimination diet for my three children. I have been on the diet too and on the two occasions I had chocolate with my husband, I had a huge headache the next day. I have been a chocoholic all my life!! I also had a headache for the first week due to withdrawals … The best thing is I am not craving sweets and the weight is dropping off me!! I am losing about half a kilo a week …” - from story [212]

"We are just amazed how much healthier our 8 year old son has been since trying to be failsafe ... Since being on the diet my children's appetite has diminished incredibly. Simply because they no longer have cravings and feel hungry after eating a meal … " - from story [1175]

2. Food intolerance symptoms – including irritable bowel, asthma, migraine, sleep disturbance and depression - can be associated with weight gain (2).

The RPAH elimination diet can often reduce these symptoms, leading to weight loss, as in this story.

“Around the middle of last year I realised that I was always tired, my workmates commented on my sneezing fits every afternoon, I was very irritable, easily reduced to tears, had rashes on my legs, an ear infection which would not clear up and generally felt unwell. But worst of all was my bloated stomach, which most times looked like I was 7 months pregnant, and the related bowel problems. Looking back I had been gradually getting worse for a couple of years…

"I bought your book and realised that all my symptoms fitted the pattern… I went on the strict diet … tried the challenges and narrowed my causes down to dairy and salicylates (both of which I had normally in large quantities)…Now I avoid all processed foods, eat failsafe at home, and make informed choices when out...The result has been a new zest for life - new role at work, back to studying part time and lots of activities. I'm back to size 12 clothes (have bought lots of new ones). I turn 50 next week and feel like 40.

"I'm a bit evangelical when I tell people why I've lost so much weight, so I don't mind you sharing my story if it is of interest to others. Thanks again for providing the tools for me to get my life back” – story [102]"

3. Medications known to cause weight gain include antidepressants, some asthma medications, steroids and many more (3).

As the RPAH elimination diet resolves these health issues, medications may be dropped.

“Three years ago I started the RPAH elimination diet, with chronic urticaria, asthma and depression, weighing in at nearly 100kgs and only 26 years old. I had to change to live. Immediately I stopped smoking and drinking and discovered after 2 days of elimination I was suffering dairy intolerance and now stay right away from all dairy products. Within 12 months I had lost 30kgs and never felt better in my life " - from story [285].

1536

“This time last year, as you can see in the pics I was severely overweight…. The other pics are of me today, 60kgs weight loss (have literally halved my weight),… haven't needed a single puff of ventolin since going failsafe or the constant courses of steroids, off all medication for stomach ulcers and migraines. I sleep through the night most nights (Well as good as you can sleep through with a toddler in the bed), I no longer need to race to the toilet often and the greatest part of all migraine free…

"Whilst I don't recommend failsafe as a weight loss solution, it has definitely played a big part in my overall journey. I didn't drop 60kgs just changing the food I was eating, I have worked very hard with daily exercise and learning portion control and getting into the habit of eating smaller portions but more frequently (I would usually only eat one meal a day but then eat a lot of munchies at night), I now eat 6 times a day, 3 meals plus 3 snacks. I wouldn't be able to exercise as I do if I wasn't feeling well or tired all the time. I wouldn't have stuck out the food changes if it hadn't changed my life in such a positive way” - from story [1536]

4. Most effective weightloss diet in the world

A 2017 New Zealand study (4) showed participants lost an average of 11.5 kg (25.3 pounds) at one year - the largest weight loss of any controlled trial where they didn’t have to go hungry or do exercise. The very low-fat, whole food plant-based (WFPB) diet has been called “the healthiest diet on the planet” because it can prevent or reverse heart disease, diabetes, obesity, cancer, dementia, and many more, is increasingly recommended by doctors all over the world. However, the WFPB diet can be extremely high in salicylates, so people with food intolerances need to know about the effects of natural salicylates in “healthy” foods (See our free Failsafe plant-based booklet). As well, those on medications need to know about the effects of salicylates and food additives such as artificial colours and preservatives in medications.

“I had to give up all food additives and chemicals at the age of 55 because of the physical and mental problems they were causing me. Now I just eat veggies and fruit. Nothing else. I lost 137 pounds (62 kg) in 18 months. I am 5 feet 6 inches tall and at 137 pounds. So I'm at a 50/50 weight loss ... 137 lost and I weigh 137. I think I may have finally found my body's equilibrium where it wants to hang out at :-) I keep going up and down a pound or 2 or 3 every few days …

The youtube video that started me on the diet September 2011 is the Last Heart Attack by Dr Sanjay Gupta. (See a 1.29min video extract of Dr Gupta interviewing Cleveland Clinic cardiologist Dr Caldwell Esselstyn https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7hiVD53aBU)

"Among the reasons I forced myself to do this diet was to get the weight off of my spine as I have a lower back spine injury and can't take pain meds for the past few years as they make me suicidal and cause me more pain. Also the main artery in my heart - the left descending artery - is 40% blocked but not enough for a stent. So my family doctor told me not to worry about it until I need a stent. Like what!!! Needless to say I didn't listen to him. I now have a cardiologist who is going to see me once a year in September and see how my blockage is doing and if it gets better or worse with this diet ... No wonder the USA population is so sickly and diseased. If people would eat real food and not what man has created, they would see things change. As Jack LaLanne (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_LaLanne) always said "if man made it...don't eat it"" - from story [1269] 

“Under the supervision of a dietician, I embarked on my Food Intolerance Journey 2 .5 years ago. I had no idea it would become my ticket to a transformation in wellbeing, energy and better health! I should point out that we are at the extreme end of the spectrum with a heavily restricted diet (WFPB). A dietician’s fine toothed comb has decreed that it contains all the necessary nutrients that my children need to grow and that I need to train hard and compete well, as an athlete. I am a triathlete, and race triathlon (swim, bike and run)…..” - from story [1240]

5. Potato-only diet

The simplest version of a failsafe plant-based diet would have to be the potato-only diet consisting of 20 potatoes per day for 2 months, eaten by American Chris Voigt from the Washington Potato Commission to prove that potatoes are healthy, nutritious and slimming. Over 60 days, Chris lost 17 lbs (7.7 kg) and his cholesterol and other health indicators improved enormously.Since then, potato-only diets have become common (note: white peeled potatoes are failsafe but we are not recommending eating them alone), with many followers explaining that it helped them to overcome their food craving and switch to a mostly plant based diet. For more information about how to follow a whole food plant-based diet, see our free Failsafe plant-based booklet 

“The potato is one of the most near complete foods on earth. One potato provides 45% of the daily requirement of Vitamin C, the protein of half a glass of milk, more potassium than a banana, fibre, and other B vitamins and minerals” – from Chris Voigt story https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6geD1kKIWlY

6.  Commercial weight loss programs

Failsafers say it is possible to lose weight using their products but read the label and avoid problematic food chemicals.

“After I undertook the elimination diet, my dietician at the RPAH clinic concluded that I was very sensitive to salicylates and I also had some milder reactions to quite a few other substances but not amines. I am now without too many problems although trying to modify my diet when I attended Weight Watchers was a bit of challenge. However, I did eventually manage to lose 10 kg” - from story [362]

“When I started on the Weight Watchers program, everything was going well for the first few days then I developed gastric problems. I was losing weight but I had terrible stomach pains all the time, so I had to give it up after six weeks and the problem stopped. Yes, I was eating their products” – from story [1241]

“I thought you may be interested in the list of ingredients to be found in the Tony Ferguson "healthy and nourishing" weight loss product ... It was only when I kept becoming hugely bloated with griping abdominal pains that I decided to check the ingredients and found - shock horror - Flavour Enhancer 621 (MSG of course!)” - from story [1100]

“I started using Tony Ferguson (weight loss meal replacement) shakes last year and managed to lose 10 kg. Three months later I started using the soups as well. Around that time I developed a painful and desperately itchy rash mainly on my leg and sometimes it would spread to other parts of my body. My doctor gave me steroid cream and I didn't realise the cause of the rash until I heard you speak. When I looked at the packets, the soups I had been eating all contained flavour enhancers you talked about (621, 627, 631, 635). When I stopped eating them the rash went away” – from story [1099]

“I have been suffering from extremely labile blood pressure since 1995. The worst problem associated with this has been raised BP within an hour or two of going to sleep. I wake feeling unwell, head hurting, cold extremities, always need to urinate, and at times, shivering uncontrollably. I used to suffer from palpitations with it - but in recent times this is rare. I've been investigated for everything possible over the years. I am inclined to eat organic food and always watch the labels on any packaged food.

"About 5 weeks ago I decided to join Jenny Craig as I felt I needed to lose up to 10 kilos and have been struggling to get this weight off. In the first week I was appalled to see how many 'numbers' were listed in the food. I could not eat things like their packaged snacks - with colours, flavours etc in them. At this point I consulted with them and asked for the food to be adjusted to suit not eating some of the colours that I know are not good, any sweeteners and Nitrates/Nitrites. This gave me a very limited list - and I could not avoid some Sulphites and Flavour Enhancers. I began to notice 635 coming up in many of the foods - and even most of the dinners.

"By about 3 weeks into the food I woke feeling really bad with the old symptoms - including a feeling of pressure in my chest (which had been vaguely there the night before) and blood pressure that measured 217/114. As it did not reduce after a short while of sitting up (my usual method of allowing my bp to lower) I went to the local hospital. They did an ECG and gave me 1/2 Anginine and O2 which eased the symptoms. When the doctor found that my mother had Angina he suggested a Thallium Stress Test. This has been completed and the results are normal.

"I have often since 95 suffered from a slight 'pain' in the chest - once definitely after eating a very tasty bowl of Chinese soup. I lived in Singapore for almost 12 years - but it was not until 95 when I was home for a short while and working on a camp site - eating mass produced food that these symptoms started to occur regularly...hence the visits to many doctors and specialists - always with a negative result for whatever they tested for. Food additives simply did not occur to me.

"A few days after my recent visit to hospital, I thought - how dumb can I be?! ... it's the food! I stopped the JC food and within 36 hours began to feel well again. Some of the JC food has 627 and 631listed together and some has 635 listed. Many of the foods also contain the hidden MSGs such as HVP.

"I now have a letter from my doctor to say that there is evidence that I am highly sensitive to vaso-active food additives ... and will be given a refund by JC. This has been an 'interesting' exercise that may finally give me the answer to my very labile BP and all the odd symptoms that seem to go with it" - from story [873]. Note Jenny Craig has closed in some countries but in Australia and New Zealand has been taken over. Reviews say it still relies on “heavily prepackaged food”.

7. Low fat failsafe

The science suggests that diets low in fat can reduce menopausal symptoms such as hot flushes as well as reducing overweight (7). Here is a story from Rosemaree over a year [1404]

“Hot flushes are driving me mad especially at night, sometimes keeping me awake at night for a few hours. I saw that your Women’s Health factsheet suggests a low fat diet. I find it really hard to be low fat on the failsafe diet. I will make some changes slowly to see if it has an effect on the hot flushes. It would be good to lose some weight too.

"After 3 weeks I have made some progress on the low fat diet. Since I started my sleep has been better and I have had no nights staying awake for hours and go to sleep quicker. I still get hot flushes but they don't seem to be as intense and are not worrying me so much. I have lost some weight, gone down a hole in my belt. I very rarely have IBS now and I put it down to more fibre in my diet. It improved once I started having gf weetbix for breakfast and upped my vegetable intake. Not keen to eat fatty sugary food - must have lost the addiction to it.

"After 3 months I have lost about 8 kilos since going on the low fat diet, clothes are hanging off me. It seems the best way to lose weight is to not try to lose weight! I have been experimenting with ways to change recipes to no fat or low fat and have minimal menopause symptoms. What annoys me is everything you read about how to help menopause never mentions to try a low fat diet. (Other than from you).

"After 12 months I have lost about 17 kilos. I am down to size 8 after being size 14 for years. Can’t get enough calories into me without fat! People are saying "Don't lose any more weight”. I have found that my fat intake has a direct effect on my menopause symptoms. If I eat more fat the symptoms creep back.”

My Typical day

Breakfast: gluten free weetbix with low fat milk, decaf with sugar

I sometimes have scrambled eggs with 1 whole egg and 2 egg whites and chives, or an occasional boiled egg, not very often. It does affect the hot flushes I am sure so don't eat them often which I find annoying as we have our own chooks.

Morning tea: failsafe hummus made with water, not oil and some plain sakatas or cruskits or a fat free muffin

Lunch: Leftovers or homemade soup or homemade pie with potato pastry or chicken and salad or a chicken, lettuce and failsafe hummus sandwich. I use the Laucke gf bread, mostly without nuttelex. Afternoon tea: A pear and a few cashews or sometimes a piece of fat free cake or a slice

Only water or decaf to drink almost every day (occasional lemonade)

Dinner: Steamed fish and salad or chicken breast and veg or lentil sauce with spaghetti or rice or No Tomato spaghetti sauce (make my own low fat mince out of steak) or chicken and chickpea casserole with dumplings or steak casserole or rice noodles with veg and chicken or San Choy Bau or chicken spring rolls. I do a Roast on Sundays, mostly chicken, sometimes lamb or beef. I do notice more hot flushes if I have lamb. Usually do something with leftover roast on Mondays.

Sweets: I often have sweets. When I don't have energy/time to do anything else we have pear and spoon of yoghurt (sometimes a squirt of carob syrup). Otherwise we have rice, sago, custard and there are a few no fat or low fat recipes I have like carob mousse, carob self saucing pudding, pear jam steamed pudding, a Rice pear dish, a couple of rhubarb dishes. Rarely I have a sponge carob biscuit in the evening.

Some recipes:

Potato pastry (contains wheat, dairy and egg)

Combine 1 egg white and 2 tbsp water, stir into 1 and a half cups of mashed potato cold. Add 1 and a half cups of plain flour and half a cup of skim milk powder. Use like pastry.

Delicious carob black bean brownies

San Choy Bau

I either buy mince and cook it with a little bit of water and drain the fat off or make my own fat free mince, and I don’t use oil http://www.cookingforoscar.com/2013/06/07/san-choy-bau-two-ways/

8. Successful losers

The National Weight Control Registry started in 1994 with a study of nearly 800 long term weight losers who had lost an average of 30 kg and successfully kept off at least 13 kg for an average of five years (8). The researchers now follow over 10,000 long term weight losers at www.nwcr.ws

What do these successful losers have in common? The majority

• eat a low fat diet (less than 1% do keto)
• do about 1 hour of moderate intensity exercise per day
• watch less than 10 hours TV per week
• eat fewer foods from fast-food restaurants (less than one per week) and fewer meals in non-fast-food restaurants (about 2.5 per week) than average. "The majority of meals eaten by registry members were prepared or eaten at home".

References

1. UPFs and weight gain

Hall KD et al, Ultra-Processed Diets Cause Excess Calorie Intake and Weight Gain: An Inpatient Randomized Controlled Trial of Ad Libitum Food Intake. Cell Metab. 2019 Jul 2;30(1):226. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7959109/

2. IBS etc symptoms can contribute to weight gain

Ho W and Spiegel BM, The relationship between obesity and functional gastrointestinal disorders, Gastroenterol Hepatol (NY),2008;4(8):572-8. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3096111/
Greer SM et al, The impact of sleep deprivation on food desire in the human brain. Nat Commun. 2013:6;4:2259 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3763921/

3. Medications can cause weight gain

Domecq JP, Prutsky G, Wang Z, Elraiyah T, Brito JP, Mauck K, Lababidi MH, Leppin A, Fidahussein S, Prokop LJ, Montori VM, Murad MH. Drugs commonly associated with weight change: umbrella systematic review and meta-analysis (Protocol). Syst Rev. 2012 Sep 29;1:44. doi: 10.1186/2046-4053-1-44. PMID: 23020969; PMCID: PMC3582551. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3582551/

4. Most effective weight loss diet 

Wright N, Wilson L, Smith M, Duncan B, McHugh P. The BROAD study: A randomised controlled trial using a whole food plant-based diet in the community for obesity, ischaemic heart disease or diabetes. Nutr Diabetes. 2017 Mar 20;7(3):e256. doi: 10.1038/nutd.2017.3. PMID: 28319109; PMCID: PMC5380896. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5380896/

5. Potato-only diet

Spudman: All potato diet 8 years later https://spudman.com/article/all-potato-diet-eight-years-later-voigt/

6. Commercial weight loss programs 

Healthline Jenny Craig diet review https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/jenny-craig-diet-review#TOC_TITLE_HDR_1

7. Low fat diet reduces menopausal symptoms 

Barnard ND, Kahleova H, Holtz DN, Del Aguila F, Neola M, Crosby LM, Holubkov R. The Women's Study for the Alleviation of Vasomotor Symptoms (WAVS): a randomized, controlled trial of a plant-based diet and whole soybeans for postmenopausal women. Menopause. 2021 Jul 12;28(10):1150-1156. doi: 10.1097/GME.0000000000001812. PMID: 34260478; PMCID: PMC8462449. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34260478/

Low fat diets for weight loss

Turner-McGrievy GM, Barnard ND, Scialli AR. A two-year randomized weight loss trial comparing a vegan diet to a more moderate low-fat diet. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2007 15(9):2276-81. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17890496/ and https://www.webmd.com/women/reducing-dietary-fat

8. Successful losers

Shick SM, Wing RR, Klem ML, McGuire MT, Hill JO, Seagle H. Persons successful at long-term weight loss and maintenance continue to consume a low-energy, low-fat diet. J Am Diet Assoc. 1998;98(4):408-13. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9550162

The most comprehensive study of long-term weight loss ever conducted, the National Weight Control Registry, found that the vast majority of its nearly 4,500 successful people followed a program that involved daily exercise and an eating plan low in fat and very high in fiber-rich carbohydrates like vegetables and fruit. The members lost, on average, 66 pounds and, at six-year follow-up, had kept it off. Less than 1% followed a high-protein, high-fat diet.

There are now 10,000 successful losers in this study, see more at the NWCR website http://www.nwcr.ws/Research/default.htm

More info

Intro to food intolerance

See our free Failsafe plant-based booklet

www.fedup.com.au

The information given is not intended as medical advice. Always consult with your doctor for underlying illness. Before beginning dietary investigation, consult a dietician with an interest in food intolerance. You can see our list of experienced and supportive dietitians http://fedup.com.au/support/failsafe-dietitians 

© Sue Dengate updated January 2025

line1